Roxy the Bed Bug Dog: The End of Secure Property Rights in Working Animals? – Reason
Not Roxy at all, but Buster, a dog with no useful skills whatsoever.
Roxy is a "specially trained bed bug sniffing dog," owned by M & M Environmentala bed bug exterminatorand kept for four years at the home of M & M employee Barry Myrick; Myrick and Roxy "work[ed] together visiting homes and business to determine whether bed bugs were present." Myrick had agreed at the outset that he "must return Roxy to M&M immediately upon the request of the Employer or upon the conclusion of my employment." The company paid for Roxy's food and medical care.
In March 2020, Myrick was either laid off or quit (there's a dispute about), but never returned Roxy. M & M sued to get Roxy back so she could "resume her bed bug sniffing duties" (M & M Environmental v. Myrick), but Monday New York trial court Judge Paul A. Goetz said no:
Traditionally under New York law, dogs and other companion animals such as Roxy have been treated as personal property. However, in light of the many protections afforded animals under the law, a growing body of case law has started to recognize that dogs fall within a special category of property that is treated differently from other types of personal inanimate property (Ferger v Warwick Animal Shelter, 59 AD3d 68 [2nd Dept 2008] [observing that trusts may now be created for pets upon the death or incapacitation of their human companions and pets may now be included in orders of protection issued by Family Court]). The question then arises what standard should be applied when determining custody and ownership of this special category of personal property.
In Travis v Murray, the court, in the context of a divorce action, was called upon to decide with whom Joey, a miniature dachshund, should live. After a thoughtful and extensive survey of the law concerning pets, the Travis Court determined that the most appropriate standard to apply when deciding with whom a pet should reside is the one found in the First Department case, Raymond v Lachmann (264 AD2d 340, 341 [1st Dept 1999]), the "best for all concerned" standard.
{Other courts have cited Raymond for the proposition that the appropriate standard is a "best interest of the animal" standard. (Feger, 59 AD3d at 72 [deciding appropriateness of a protective order to prevent disclosure of the identities of the donor and adoptive owner of a cat sought by plaintiff]; LeConte v Lee, 35 Misc. 3d 286, 288 [Civ Ct, NY Co 2011] [deciding replevin action between former paramours]).}
The Travis court detailed the factors to consider when applying the "best for all concerned" standard and indicated that it would hold a hearing at which the parties would be given an opportunity to prove not only why she will benefit from having Joey in her life but why Joey has a better chance of living, prospering, loving and being loved in the care of one spouse as opposed to the other. The factors the Court set out include who bore the major responsibility for meeting Joey's needs (i.e. feeding, walking, grooming and taking him to the veterinarian) and who spent more time with Joey on a regular basis. Outside the matrimonial action context, trial courts have also applied the best for all concerned standard when determining ownership and custody of pets (Mitchell v Snider, 51 Misc 3d 1229 [Civ Ct NY Co 2016] [replevin action between former paramours]; Ramseur v Askins, 44 Misc 3d 1209 [A] [Civ Ct Bx Co 2014] [replevin action between nephew and aunt]; see also Hennet v Allan, 543 Misc 3d 542 [SC Albany Co 2014] [citing Travis in determining that the dispute between two former paramours required a hearing as to which party "has the most genuine right of possession"]).
[T]he question is not whether [M & M] holds "title" to her but rather whether [M & M] or [Myrick] has the superior right to custody of Roxy taking into account that she falls within a "special category of property." When resolving competing claims of who owns a dog, application of the best for all concerned standard is appropriate because it takes into account the special nature of dogstheir needs and well-beingas well as the competing claims by the parties.
Applying the best for all concerned standard and the straightforward factors set out by the court in Travis, on this record, [M & M] has not established a likelihood of success on the merits to warrant ordering Roxy's return to [M & M]. [M & M] does not submit evidence that it endeavored to meet any of Roxy's needs such as feeding, walking and grooming her. [M & M] merely reimbursed [Myrick] for food and veterinarian care; [Myrick] has been the party responsible for ensuring that Roxy has been properly feed and kept in good health.
Footing the bill for food and veterinarian care, without more, is insufficient to establish that [M & M] was meeting Roxy's needs. Nor does [M & M] allege that any of its other employees or [owners] spent any time with Roxy on a regular basis and there is no dispute that she has lived with [Myrick] for the past four years.
Prime evidence on this record that Roxy is well cared for by [Myrick] was not submitted by [Myrick] but rather by [M & M]. The YouTube video [M & M] linked to in its papers demonstrates that [Myrick] and Roxy have developed a deep mutual bond between them over the last four years. Removing Roxy from the home where she has grown and thrived, as evidenced in the YouTube video, for the past four years would likely cause her a great deal of distress and would not be in her or [Myrick]'s best interest.
[M & M]'s expense in acquiring Roxy and any compensable quantifiable business loses incurred as result of her not being deployed on [M & M]'s behalf may be awarded at a future date and do not outweigh the harm it will likely cause to Roxy and [Myrick] by ordering Roxy's return to [M & M].
I can see the arguments for the law recognizing the interests of dogs and similar animals, including their bonds with people they've lived with; perhaps this New York approach is indeed better than the traditional approach, where the owners have control over where and with whom the dog lives and works.
But I wanted to flag this, because it does seem like a serious departure from the traditional approachand one that would apply to a wide range of working animals (at least as long as they are working for a company, rather than just for a sole proprietor). After all, in most companies that use such animals, the animal will be taken care of by employees and not the company owners; and often the animal will be taken care of by one particular employee more than by others. The sort of human-animal bonding that the judge found here will likely happen in many such cases; and, if this decision is followed, companies will no longer be able to have any confidence that, when the employee quits, they'll be able to continue using the animal. Maybe that's fine, but it strikes me as worth thinking about.
Here is the original post:
Roxy the Bed Bug Dog: The End of Secure Property Rights in Working Animals? - Reason
- Toronto tenants accuse property manager of freezing them in their apartments - blogTO - February 27th, 2021
- Eco-Friendly Solutions for the Top 5 Pests - EcoWatch - February 25th, 2021
- Serenity at Highland still troubled by dangerous conditions - wreg.com - February 25th, 2021
- Hove mum's 'fear' after being told she could be 'homeless' - The Argus - February 21st, 2021
- Leeds named as one of UK's bed bugs hotspot with people leaving bed sheets unwashed for nearly 3 weeks - Leeds Live - February 19th, 2021
- Pandemic Adds Roach Infestations To Its List of Living Nightmares - Gothamist - February 19th, 2021
- SaniSnooze Hits the Market - HomeCare - February 17th, 2021
- Dont let the bed bugs bite - Bangalore Mirror - February 17th, 2021
- Toronto residents deliver cockroaches to landlords trying to evict them - blogTO - February 17th, 2021
- Who is doing what to your clothes and your house? | Witness - News24 - February 17th, 2021
- Push to extend foster care from age 18 to 21 could keep more young adults with services they need - The Arizona Republic - February 14th, 2021
- Assassins and Hunters Lurk in the Shadows - North Country Public Radio - February 14th, 2021
- Jax Sheets on Shark Tank: What is the cost, who is the founder and why is it billed as bedsheets for men? - MEAWW - February 14th, 2021
- The US structural pest control market by revenue is expected to grow at a CAGR of over 5% during the period 20212026 - GlobeNewswire - February 12th, 2021
- This City Has the Worst Bed Bug Infestation in America - AOL - February 12th, 2021
- The US structural pest control market by revenue is expected to grow at a CAGR of over 5% during the period 20212026 - Press Release - Digital Journal - February 10th, 2021
- Ilze Hattingh used early-career hardships to become an ASU standout - The State Press - February 10th, 2021
- RCMP and CBSA investigation leads to the arrest of six individuals and the dismantling of a large human trafficking network - Benzinga - February 10th, 2021
- Last Week in The Sentinel | Local News | sentinelsource.com - The Keene Sentinel - February 7th, 2021
- Congrats, Cincinnati! We're Among Orkin's Top Bed Bug Cities - Cincinnati CityBeat - February 5th, 2021
- The History of the Bookworm - Book Riot - February 5th, 2021
- Chicago tops list of cities for bed bug infestations - The Denver Channel - February 3rd, 2021
- Bedbugs: symptoms, treatment and how to get rid of them - Netdoctor - February 3rd, 2021
- Here's what to do if you have bedbugs - Yahoo Lifestyle UK - February 3rd, 2021
- 'Bed Bug Cities' Ranking Puts Flint High on the List - wcrz.com - February 3rd, 2021
- Parenting In Focus: Childhood nightmares and remedies - Sequim Gazette - February 3rd, 2021
- Baltimore Comes In Second On Orkin's List Of Cities With Most Bed Bugs - Yahoo News - February 3rd, 2021
- This US city has the most bed bugs - Fox Business - February 1st, 2021
- New Year, New Top City on Orkin's 2021 Bed Bug Cities List: Chicago - PRNewswire - February 1st, 2021
- Who said there's no good news from this Covid-19 pandemic? You don't have to worry so much about bed bugs now - RT - January 28th, 2021
- Assassins and Hunters Lurk in the Shadows - - The Adirondack Almanack - Adirondack Almanack - January 28th, 2021
- Toronto tops list of worst cities for bed bugs in 2020 - CTV Toronto - January 27th, 2021
- These are the 25 worst cities in Canada for bed bugs | News - Daily Hive - January 27th, 2021
- This northern Ontario city is one of Canada's top 10 for bed bugs - CTV Toronto - January 27th, 2021
- These Are Cities That Top the List for Bed Bug Infestations in Canada for 2020 - To Do Canada - January 27th, 2021
- Housing options for medically vulnerable people are limited as PEP-V centers hover at capacity - Greater Greater Washington - January 27th, 2021
- Toronto is once again the top bed bug city in Canada - indie88.com - January 27th, 2021
- Vancouver ranks #4 most bed bug-infested city in Canada - Vancouver Is Awesome - January 27th, 2021
- Winter at the borders of Europe: fears for refugees - PRESSENZA International News Agency - January 27th, 2021
- The FINANCIAL - University spin-out battles bed bugs with pheromone innovation - The FINANCIAL - January 25th, 2021
- Bed Bugs: How to Get Rid of Them Effectively? - Gilmore Health News - January 25th, 2021
- Garth Rattray | Non-contact infrared thermometers are safe - Jamaica Gleaner - January 25th, 2021
- The areas where Warwick District Council has been called to deal with rats, mice and cockroaches - Coventry Live - January 24th, 2021
- Residents of Lansing's Porter Apartments describe rats, bedbugs and unresponsive owners - WSYM-TV - January 22nd, 2021
- Tenant's nightmare in high-rise flat infested with bed bugs, silverfish and beetles - Glasgow Live - January 20th, 2021
- The One Product Americans Will Need When They Return to Traveling - The Ritz Herald - January 20th, 2021
- The #1 Reason You Should Avoid This New, Trending Supplement - Eat This, Not That - January 20th, 2021
- Who Is The Most Famous Celebrity Ever? We Have The Answer - unCrazed - January 18th, 2021
- DIY Pest Control Products Market 2021 Growing Demand and Research Report Henkel, Spectrum, Bell Labs, Ensystex, Thermacell, Nisus Corp - The Courier - January 16th, 2021
- The Office: The Best Episode Of Every Season, Ranked According To IMDb - Screen Rant - January 14th, 2021
- The cicada's deafening shriek is the sound of summer, and humans have been drawn to it for thousands of years - The Conversation AU - January 11th, 2021
- Afraid Of Rodents And Bugs? 2021 May Not Be Your Year - PRNewswire - January 8th, 2021
- Disinfection exercise has minimised bedbugs in schools in the Northern region---Regional Education Director - Modern Ghana - January 8th, 2021
- Guelph Public Library wants you to stop (literally) cooking the books - GuelphToday - January 8th, 2021
- Judge orders probation and treatment in cancer scam case - Daily Local News - January 6th, 2021
- Released Inmates at Durham's COVID Motel Say It's Just Another Prison - INDY Week - January 6th, 2021
- How to Get Rid of Silverfish in Your House, According to Pest Control Experts - Prevention.com - January 4th, 2021
- Insects and the cold - Plainview Daily Herald - December 31st, 2020
- Bed bugs: The smells warning of an infestation including a marzipan odour - TechnoCodex - December 31st, 2020
- The Road: 100 Days of Travel in Pandemic-Ravaged America - Rolling Stone - December 29th, 2020
- Europe pest control market Outlook and Opportunities in Grooming Regions - LionLowdown - December 25th, 2020
- Python-sniffing dogs are Florida's newest weapon in fighting invasive snakes - ABC News - December 23rd, 2020
- Sniffing Out Pythons: Dogs Being Used To Track Invasive Burmese Pythons - CBS Miami - December 22nd, 2020
- At least we don't have communal bed bugs - The Chatham News + Record - December 17th, 2020
- 'The prison's message is: Cooperate or you'll go back to the cell and be eaten alive by bugs' - Haaretz.com - December 17th, 2020
- Immune and circulatory systems are functionally integrated in all insects, Vanderbilt biologists demonstrate - Vanderbilt University News - December 17th, 2020
- Light of Life Rescue Mission opening two facilities on the North Side - NEXTpittsburgh - December 15th, 2020
- Family worries as shelter strained by virus outbreak - Midland Daily News - December 13th, 2020
- Co-op and Condo Annual Bedbug Reports Are Almost Due - Habitat magazine - December 11th, 2020
- Tenants of Rabbi Shulman Apartments in South Bend being relocated - 953mnc.com - December 9th, 2020
- How To Determine The Type Of Termite Infestation - KHTS Radio - December 9th, 2020
- How often you should wash pyjamas and the nasty health risks if you don't - RSVP Live - December 9th, 2020
- Bed bugs reported at Edgewater apartments - BayToday.ca - December 4th, 2020
- Bed bug bites: Signs can be found close to blood vessels - key locations to look for - Express - December 4th, 2020
- The 12 Best Steam Cleaners, According to People Who Really, *Really* Love Them - PureWow - December 4th, 2020
- A one-stop solution for all crawl spaces and attic related problems by Diversified CrawlSpace Services - Press Release - Digital Journal - December 1st, 2020
- A cleaning expert has warned about making your bed first thing in the morning - FM104 - November 28th, 2020
- Bed bug cases on the rise since 2010 | AgriLife Today - AgriLife Today - November 27th, 2020
- Early Detection, Topical Steroids, and Antihistamines, May Be Helpful for Combatting Bed Bug Manifestations - Dermatology Advisor - November 27th, 2020
- The immune and circulatory systems are functionally integrated across insect evolution - Science Advances - November 27th, 2020